June 6th, 2020

I read No Exit by Jean-Paul Sartre. It reminded me of a Nobel Sansyouuo by Masuji Ibuse. The both story’s theme is imprisonment. No Exit.

サルトル出口なしを読みました。それは、井伏鱒二山椒魚を思い出させました。両方の物語とも、テーマは幽閉です。出口がないんです。

Then, I thought Masuji’s Sansyouuo is much simpler to explain about imprisonment.

私は井伏鱒二の山椒魚の方が、幽閉について簡潔に語られてると思いました。

Sartre’s is that the interaction between men and women is distracting from the main subject.

サルトルのそれは、男女のやりとりが、本題から気を散らしてしまうのです。

However, Sartre wanted to talk about existence in this story,

だけど、サルトルはこの作品で存在について語りたかったんだから、

I am the stupid one that compares these stories.

私はこの二つの物語を比較する愚かな人です。

2 thoughts on “June 6th, 2020”

  1. From Jean Paul Sartre to Masuji Ibuse seems seriously impressive reading! Heart rendering ruminations on notions of existence, freedoms and suffering. I read Black Rain many years ago – it was life changing.

    1. Dear Pamela,
      I have not read Black Rain yet. I’ve just ordered the book.
      I have a favorite poem.
      It is a poem written by Tang Dynasty poet Ubu Ryou. It was translated by Ibuse. I love Ibuse’s translation very much. Do you know this poem?
      Ubu Ryou’s title is 勧酒 Toast. But, Ibuse’s transrated title is サヨナラだけが人生だ Sayonara dake ga jinnseida. I can say it in English- “life is only for goodbye(farewell)”. But, if I have better English skills it could say nicer.
      Ibuse’s translation shows his genius.
      I put a rink that explain the poem. Sorry, it is not English. But, I think you can figure it out because you can read Chinese.
      http://ogikubo-bunshi.a.la9.jp/toku-kanshu.html

Comments are closed.